Go/no-go criteria are the pass-fail tests you apply to a commercial loan scenario before you spend lender goodwill on it. For a broker, the core set is repayment capacity (cash flow and DSCR), leverage, borrower liquidity and experience, collateral, exit strategy, and documentation. Score each one, define which failures are deal-killers, and the decision becomes one of four outcomes: advance, revise, pause or decline.
TL;DR
- Screen every scenario on the same eight factors: credit, liquidity, experience, property quality, cash flow/DSCR, leverage, exit and documentation.
- Set deal-killers before you score. A zero on credit, exit or documentation should stop the deal, whatever the other numbers say.
- Use a 0 to 3 scale per category and map total scores to four actions: advance, revise, pause, decline.
- Tighten the screen by loan type. A DSCR loan, a bridge loan and a ground-up construction loan fail for different reasons.
- Write the decision and the reason down. It is the fastest way to improve your hit rate with lenders.
Table of Contents
- Why brokers need a go/no-go screen
- The core go/no-go criteria for a CRE loan scenario
- Regulatory benchmarks worth knowing
- Build a go/no-go matrix you will actually use
- A loan screening checklist for the intake call
- Adjust the framework by loan type
- What to do when a deal fails a criterion
- Perspective
- Put the screen into your pipeline
- FAQ
- Sources
Why brokers need a go/no-go screen
Every weak submission costs you twice. It burns hours on packaging, and it teaches the lender that your name on a file means more work. A screen you run in ten minutes protects both.
Most of what ranks for this keyword is written for project managers or RFP teams: should we bid, should we ship the release. The logic carries over to loan placement, but the criteria differ. A broker is not deciding whether the project is worth doing. A broker is deciding whether this scenario, as it stands today, is worth taking to lenders, and to which ones.
The practical outcomes are simple. One reviewer who scores CRE deals suggests shopping strong deals selectively, demanding fixes before resubmitting weak ones, or walking away. That is the whole decision tree, and the rest of this article is how to make it consistently.
The core go/no-go criteria for a CRE loan scenario
The federal bank regulator's handbook is a good anchor, because lenders are examined against it. The OCC says commercial real estate underwriting should analyze the borrower's global financial condition, the guarantor's responsibility, the nature and value of the collateral, and the borrower's capacity and willingness to repay (OCC, Commercial Real Estate Lending 2.0). Translate that into questions a broker can answer from an intake call.
1. Repayment capacity: cash flow and DSCR
Put this first. The OCC says underwriting should determine whether the borrower can meet a realistic repayment plan from available cash flow and liquidity, including property cash flow and other indicators of borrower capacity. The ABA likewise says cash flow is usually the primary source of loan repayment.
Check two things: does stated NOI cover debt service at the proposed rate, and are the revenue and vacancy assumptions believable? A ratio that clears on paper means little if rents are aggressive. The FDIC makes a related point for small-business borrowers: cash-flow analysis should reflect a reasonable range of future conditions, not only the best or worst case. Run the scenario at a slightly higher rate and a higher vacancy before you call it a go. If you need a refresher on why lenders reject a 1.25 that looked fine, see our piece on DSCR versus NOI.
2. Leverage
Loan-to-value and loan-to-cost decide which lender tier is even possible. The OCC's guidance calls for clear, measurable standards, including property-type LTV limits. Ask for the purchase price or value basis, the proposed loan amount and how much hard equity the sponsor is putting in. The CREFC underwriting principles describe lower-risk loans as those with substantial collateral value and significant sponsor cash equity. A request that needs almost no equity is not an automatic no, but it narrows your lender list sharply and should be scored that way.
3. Borrower credit, liquidity and net worth
Lenders look at the sponsor as well as the building. Gather credit profile, post-closing liquidity, net worth and any contingent liabilities. A weak credit story is not always fatal, but an unexplained one is. Know the reason for any late payments or judgments before the lender asks.
4. Sponsor and management experience
The CREFC principles also stress experienced property management. A first-time investor buying a 40-unit value-add is a different conversation from a repeat operator. Experience can be offset by a strong property manager or a seasoned co-sponsor, so note what the offset is.
5. Collateral and property quality
Is the collateral financeable? Property type, condition, occupancy, location and appraisal risk all matter here. The NCUA's examiner guidance for a credit approval document lists collateral value and valuation method, LTV and environmental due diligence among the items to verify. If you already suspect a hazardous-use history or deferred capital needs, that belongs in your screen, not in a surprise at appraisal.
6. Exit strategy
For bridge, construction and fix-and-flip deals, the exit is the loan. Who takes out this lender, at what value and what rate, and what happens if that fails? A vague "we'll refinance" is a zero. Credit committees also want execution dependencies named. Sample credit committee material shows specific mitigants such as requiring property condition reports before closing or funding specific escrows against refinance timing risk. Do the same in your own summary.
7. Documentation readiness
Can you produce the rent roll, operating statements, entity documents, personal financial statement and purchase contract within a few days? Missing documents are the most fixable failure and the most common reason a good scenario stalls. Our loan document checklist lists what to collect up front.
8. Loan purpose and structure
Confirm the sources and uses, the term, the amortization and the purpose. The NCUA guidance asks that the financing amount, purpose, sources and uses, and rate and term be verified. If the borrower cannot explain where every dollar goes, stop and fix that first.
Regulatory benchmarks worth knowing
Some lenders borrow their coverage thresholds from a federal rule. Under the Federal Reserve's underwriting standards for qualifying CRE loans, the required debt service coverage is 1.5 for qualifying leased CRE, 1.25 for qualifying multifamily and 1.7 for other CRE, measured on actual performance and projections over two years. The same section requires an enforceable first lien, documented borrower and affiliate financial condition, and a qualifying written appraisal.

Treat these as reference points for the conservative end of the market, not as a rule every lender applies. Private money, debt funds and DSCR lenders set their own tests. The CREFC notes that because each property is unique, lenders customize underwriting to the facts of each loan while staying consistent. Your screen should do the same: fixed categories, flexible thresholds by lender type.
Build a go/no-go matrix you will actually use
A matrix turns opinion into a repeatable decision. One published approach scores categories from 0 to 3, with 0 meaning deal killer, and adds the scores. It names a zero in credit, exit or documentation as an automatic stop. Here is a version adapted for brokers.
| Category | 0 (deal killer) | 1 (weak) | 2 (acceptable) | 3 (strong) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Repayment capacity / DSCR | Fails at any realistic rate | Passes only on best-case numbers | Passes with a modest cushion | Passes after a stress test |
| Leverage | Little or no equity | Top of the lender's range | Mid-range | Conservative |
| Borrower credit | Unexplained serious issues | Issues with a good explanation | Clean, thin history | Strong, seasoned |
| Liquidity / net worth | Cannot close or cover reserves | Barely covers reserves | Covers reserves | Ample after closing |
| Experience | None, no offset | Limited, partial offset | Relevant track record | Repeat operator |
| Property quality | Unfinanceable condition or use | Heavy repairs needed | Average for its class | Strong, stabilized |
| Exit strategy | No credible exit | Depends on one assumption | Two plausible exits | Clear, tested exits |
| Documentation | Cannot be produced | Partial, slow | Mostly complete | Complete package |
Eight categories at 3 points each give a maximum of 24. Set your own bands, for example:
- Any zero in credit, exit or documentation: decline or pause until it is fixed.
- Total of 19 to 24: advance and shop to a focused list.
- Total of 13 to 18: revise, then resubmit to yourself before lenders.
- Below 13: decline politely, or park it until the facts change.
These cutoffs are a starting point, not an industry standard. Adjust them after you have logged 20 or 30 outcomes. Weight the categories if your niche calls for it: repayment capacity and exit deserve double weight on bridge loans, for example.
A loan screening checklist for the intake call
Use this as the first fifteen minutes with a new borrower. If you cannot answer an item, that is itself a finding.
Borrower
- Entity structure, guarantors and ownership percentages
- Credit profile and any events that need explaining
- Liquidity after closing and net worth
- Real estate owned and comparable experience
Property
- Type, location, occupancy and condition
- Current NOI and the basis for it, with three years of history where available (the NCUA guidance asks for three years of historical financials when they exist)
- Environmental or title concerns, including liens
Financing request
- Loan amount, purpose, sources and uses
- Target term, amortization and rate expectations
- Equity in and where it came from
Risks and exit
- What has to happen for the loan to be repaid, and by when
- What breaks if rates, vacancy or expenses move against the borrower
Lender fit
- Which lender types actually lend on this asset, size and leverage
- Which questions you must ask before submitting; our questions to ask lenders list covers them
Adjust the framework by loan type
The categories stay the same. The emphasis moves.
DSCR loans. The property has to carry itself, so cash flow and leverage dominate and personal income matters less. Lender thresholds vary, so match the scenario to lender criteria early. See our DSCR loan guide and the first-submission checklist.
Bridge and fix-and-flip. Exit and budget credibility decide the deal. Score the exit twice: once at the planned value and once at a haircut. Scope of work, contractor and timeline belong in the file.
Construction. Add plans, permits, budget, contingency, sponsor track record and completion risk. Lender requirements here are more detailed, and our construction lender requirements guide covers them.
Multifamily and stabilized income property. Rent roll quality, vacancy assumptions and expense ratios carry the most weight. The regulatory benchmark above is lower for multifamily, which reflects that asset class's income profile.

What to do when a deal fails a criterion
A failed criterion is a diagnosis, not a verdict. Sort the failure into one of three types.
- Fixable now. Missing documents, an unexplained credit item, unclear sources and uses. Fix them, rescore, then shop.
- Fixable by restructuring. Too much leverage, a thin DSCR, a fragile exit. Reduce the loan amount, add equity or a co-guarantor, extend the term, or change the loan type. Rescore the new structure.
- Not fixable. No exit, no equity, an unfinanceable asset. Decline, and tell the borrower what would need to change to bring it back.
Deals with dependencies deserve a written plan for each. If closing hinges on clearing a federal tax lien, for example, lining up the paperwork early prevents last-minute delays. A walk-through of Form 14135 and lien discharge shows what that process involves. Present dependencies and mitigants to the lender up front, the way a credit committee memo would, instead of letting underwriting find them.
Perspective
We built BrokersConnect around a simple observation: most wasted broker time is spent before a deal ever gets a real answer. A scenario goes out to the wrong lenders, or to the right ones without the right facts, and then sits.
A go/no-go screen fixes the first half of that problem, and lender matching fixes the second. When you know a deal's property type, loan amount, location, leverage, credit profile, purpose and structure, you can match it against lenders likely to consider it instead of working down a list and cold calling.
That is why we put scenario submission, a lender database of 289+ verified lenders, a deal pipeline and tracking of lender conversations in one place. Our view is that screening, packaging and outreach should be one workflow, not three disconnected tools. The screen tells you which deals deserve your time. The platform helps you place them.
Theron
Put the screen into your pipeline
A matrix on paper works until volume rises. Then you want the score, the notes and the lender outreach attached to the same deal record.
BrokersConnect is a commercial real estate financing platform built for brokers: AI-powered lender matching, deal scenario submission, batch lender outreach, a deal pipeline CRM, a secure document vault and AI tools for deal packaging. It costs $50 per month with a free trial, and there are no commissions or transaction fees. You can see the details and start on the BrokersConnect platform.

If you want to sharpen the lender side of the decision first, read our guide to lender shortlist criteria and the loan submission guide.
FAQ
What are the criteria for a go/no-go decision on a loan?
The standard set is repayment capacity (cash flow and DSCR), leverage, borrower credit and liquidity, sponsor experience, collateral quality, exit strategy and documentation. Score each one, and decide in advance which failures are automatic stops. Credit, exit and documentation are the usual candidates.
What is the difference between a go/no-go checklist and a matrix?
A checklist confirms that you have gathered the facts. A matrix scores them and produces a decision. Use the checklist on the intake call and the matrix once you have the answers, so the score rests on verified information.
When should a broker decline a deal?
Decline when a deal-killer cannot be fixed by documents, restructuring or time: no credible exit, no real equity, or an asset lenders will not finance. If the problem is fixable, send it back to the borrower with a specific list of fixes and rescore.
Do the DSCR thresholds in federal rules apply to every lender?
No. The 1.5, 1.25 and 1.7 figures come from the Federal Reserve's rule for qualifying CRE loans, and many lenders set their own minimums. Use them as conservative reference points and confirm each lender's requirement before submitting.
Sources
- OCC, Commercial Real Estate Lending 2.0
- Federal Reserve, Section 244.17 Underwriting Standards for Qualifying CRE Loans
- NCUA, Financial Analysis and Credit Approval Document
- CREFC, Principles-Based Underwriting Framework
- FDIC, Meeting the Credit Needs of Creditworthy Small Business Borrowers
- ABA, Commercial Lending School curriculum
- Fernandes Company, sample credit committee presentation
- Real Estate Loan Viability Scorecard
- Form 14135 lien discharge
